The McMahon Report October 2026

What’s Going On in Southwest Florida? T H E S O U R C E F O R P R I V A T E C L U B E X C E L L E N C E™ OCTOBER 2026 McMahon Report® THE …AndWhat CanWe Learn?

FROM THE FOUNDER Dear Club Leaders, This issue of the McMahon Report centers on a single, connecting idea: The private club of today is being defined less by its amenities than by howwell it understands the members it already has. Whether the subject is a waitlist, a fitness center, a dining room, or a fifteen-minute drive, the same question keeps surfacing across these pages — Does your club actually knowwhat its members need, or does it only knowwhat it has always assumed they need? Consider the waiting list. For decades it was treated as proof of success, a queue that ran itself. Kevin Morganfield's piece on page 3 makes the case that a long list left unmanaged is no longer a sign of health — it's a liability, both to member goodwill and to capital revenue. Christian Coulter picks up a related thread on page 4: Golf participation isn't shrinking, but the way members consume it is changing, and clubs that widen their calendar rather than defend their tee sheet are the ones building loyalty for the next decade. David Dew and Scott Fairbairn then take us to the epicenter of that demand — Southwest Florida —where six clubs are showing what happens when membership growth outpaces supply, and what every club, regardless of location, can learn from how that region is investing in its facilities. Scott Fairbairn then turns inward, to the clubhouse itself, arguing that a crowded pool grill often isn't a staffing problem at all, but a signal that members are voting with their feet for an experience the club hasn't yet defined. Christian Clerc closes the loop with six years of member survey data on something every club feels but rarely measures precisely: the true cost of distance, and why the clubs that thrive are the ones that know exactly which kind of value — convenience or destination — they're actually selling. Taken together, these articles point to the same discipline: Don't guess at what members want. Ask, measure, and design around the answer. That's the work we do every day with clubs across the country, and it's the spirit behind everything in this issue. Sincerely, Bill McMahon, Sr., AIA, OAA McMahon Group Founder ABOUT MCMAHON GROUP Our Mission: “To be the premier club consulting firm dedicated to private club excellence by providing clubs and their management with the best possible strategic and facility planning expertise. We are committed to identifying the key trends impacting the club industry, enhancing the profession of club management and to assisting presidents and Boards with adopting the best practices to foster effective governance to create successful clubs.” Family- and managementowned since 1983 with an outstanding professional staff. We have served clubs and communities throughout the world in all aspects. OVER 2000 CLUBS SERVED OVER 150 HOA’S SERVED McMahon Group, Inc. 670 Mason Ridge Center Drive, Suite 220 St. Louis, Missouri 63141 • 314.744.5040 info@mcmahongroup.com www.mcmahongroup.com www.clubmanageraward.com www.mcmahoncommunity.com WHATWE OFFER • Strategic Planning and Implementation • Facility Planning and Funding Programs • Membership Surveys and Research • Existing Facilities Condition Analysis • HOA Community Consulting • McMahon Quality Index™ Rating Program $3.5 BILLION RAI SED 40++ I N BUSI NESS YEARS 2 The McMahon Report® For more information or to schedule a First Impressions Visit, please contact Alison McMahon at amcmahon@mcmahongroup.com. CONNECT WITH US ONLINE FOR VIDEOS, BROCHURES AND EVEN MORE UP-TO-DATE CLUB INFORMATION! Contact us to sc hedule your complimentary First Impressions visit today!

By Kevin Morganfield Consultant The McMahon Report® 3 because it's easy to explain and hard to argue with. But as some lists stretch past five, seven or even ten years, a handful of clubs have quietly started asking whether strict chronological order is still the right way to decide who comes off next, or whether other factors ought to carry some weight alongside it. This is delicate territory, and clubs are treating it that way. Any move away from pure seniority-based sequencing raises real questions about fairness, transparency, and how a change gets explained to people who've waited patiently under the old rules. We won't get into specifics of what these approaches look like here; some are still taking shape, and all carry enough sensitivity that a club considering one should think it through carefully, likely with outside counsel, before discussing it publicly. But it's worth flagging as a trend: The “how” of the waitlist is now starting to get as much attention as the “how long.” Is Your List Actually a List? Here's a less comfortable question that Boards should ask: Howmany names on that list are still real prospects? If a club never collected a deposit, or collected just a token amount, the list likely includes people who've moved, lost interest, or would decline the offer to join if it came tomorrow. That's not a minor bookkeeping issue; it skews turnover projections, misleads the Board about actual demand, and leaves decisions resting on a number that was never accurate. The fix isn't complicated, but it takes discipline: a periodic reaffirmation step that requires candidates to actively confirm continued interest, paired with a meaningful deposit going forward if one isn't already in place. For clubs with a list built without deposits, a structured outreach effort, or even a short survey asking candidates where they stand, is often the fastest way to find out how real the list actually is. It's the same discipline clubs already apply to member-satisfaction research, aimed at a population that matters just as much to understand. The Number Nobody's Watching: Capital Revenue There's a financial angle to slow-moving lists that rarely makes the conversation. Every year that a club turns over only a handful of golf memberships instead of a healthy number, it's not collecting the initiation-fee income tied to those transitions. Consider a club with a $50,000 fee converting five memberships a year instead of a more typical 12; that's a $350,000 gap in annual capital revenue, forgone simply because the list isn't moving. Low attrition can look like satisfaction on the surface, but it's also deferred revenue quietly left on the table. This is exactly why interim access and real deposit structures matter beyond the goodwill they generate. Done right, they let a club begin to capture some of that latent demand today, without overpromising when full membership will follow. Where This Leaves Clubs The waiting list can no longer be treated as a passive queue that runs itself. It's become an active part of the membership lifecycle and deserves the same attention clubs already give onboarding, retention, and member satisfaction. Waitlist strategy increasingly intersects with the strategic planning and survey work clubs already rely on. F or most of the private club industry's history, a waiting list was a good problem to have, as a sign of health and demand. That's still true. But something has changed since 2020: Lists that used to run six months to a couple of years now stretch for five, eight or even ten-plus years at some clubs. A full membership used to be the finish line of a club's growth story. Today, for a growing number of clubs, it's the start of a management problem many Boards aren't yet equipped to handle. Waiting Isn't the Problem. Waiting in Silence Is. Ask most membership directors what generates the most frustration among waitlisted candidates, and it's rarely the wait itself; it's the absence of anything happening during it. A candidate who put down a deposit a year or two ago (or more) and has heard nothing since starts to wonder if they've been forgotten. Clubs that manage this well tend to land on the same idea: Give waitlisted candidates something real to do while they wait. This could be limited golf access on off-peak days, use of the practice facility, or a social membership tier that keeps them dining and attending events. None of this requires giving up a tee time that belongs to a full member, and it keeps candidates connected to the community they're trying to join. An engaged candidate is far less likely to walk away than one who feels like a name in a drawer. Rethinking How the Line ActuallyWorks For decades, the rule on most waitlists has been simple: first come, first served. That approach has worked precisely Contact us today at 314.744.5040 or www.McMahonGroup.com The Hidden Cost of the Waitlist: Why Long Lists Need Active Management, Not Just Patience CLUB MEMBERSHIP

By Christian W. Coulter, CCM, ECM, Vice President of Club Consulting T echnology rarely changes what members want from a club. It changes what a club can give them. Lights, ball-tracking screens and automated turf equipment have together made a category of golf possible that did not exist at most clubs five years ago: golf on a weeknight, in forty minutes, without a tee time. That deserves the same attention the industry once gave fitness. Not long ago we debated seriously whether fitness belonged at a golf club, and the argument against it was reasonable: We are a golf club, and square footage devoted to treadmills is square footage taken from something with proven demand. Anyone stewarding a member-owned club had an obligation to ask. The answer turned out to be yes, and the clubs that reached it early built sooner and cheaper. The ones that arrived late retrofitted a space never meant for it and apologized for the ceiling height. The lesson was never really about fitness. It was about the calendar. A club offering one reason to visit, in good weather, on a schedule that demands half a day is competing for a small slice of a member’s life. Fitness widened the calendar. That was the actual return. Golf is Not Shrinking; It is Being Consumed Differently The constraint on golf has never been interest. It’s the block of time. Five hours plus a drive is a serious ask of someone with a job and children, so members ration their play — a full round Saturday, guilt about it, then Wednesday skipped entirely. The same member will happily hit balls for 40 minutes after work, play nine at dusk, or bring three friends out for an hour over a few beers. That is all still golf; it's just golf in smaller bites. The national numbers say it out loud. The National Golf Foundation reported U.S. participation at an all-time high of 48.1 million in 2025, with off-course golf drawing 32.6 million participants against 28.1 million oncourse. More Americans now play golf away from a golf course than on one. The appetite was never the problem. The portion size was. 4 The McMahon Report® Golf in Smaller Bites The club of yesterday added fitness. The club of tomorrow adds frequency. MORE AMERICANS ARE NOW PLAYING GOLF AWAY FROM A GOLF COURSE THAN ON ONE. THE APPETITE WAS NEVER THE PROBLEM. THE PORTION SIZE WAS. October 2026 CLUB OPERATIONS LAREDO COUNTRY CLUB

What Laredo Country Club Built Laredo (Texas) Country Club, founded in 1983, built a 19-bay covered practice and social facility (see photo, pg. 4). It features ball-tracking screens at every bay, lounge seating set back from the hitting line, lights that carry play to 10 p.m., and a full short-game complex of target greens and real bunkering. Then it measured, for 611 consecutive days. The result (see chart at right) is a demand curve most clubs never get to see. Weekday afternoons move quietly. Then the workday ends. Five p.m. occupancy climbs over 30 percent, six p.m. to over 40, and seven p.m. peaks at near 50, on a Tuesday. Eight p.m. still holds at over 40%. The busiest hours of the week at Laredo are hours during which many golf course operations in America have already closed. Saturday behaves differently and just as usefully. It doesn’t spike, it plateaus, holding at over 25 percent from noon straight through six p.m. — six unbroken hours of continuous use by members warming up before their rounds, along with members who came out just to hit. Notice What the Space Became It is not a practice tee. The lounge furniture between the bays is the reason a member brings three friends and stays 90 minutes for 40 minutes of golf. Families come out after dinner. Juniors who can’t do 18 holes will hit for an hour and love it. Most significantly, the facility reaches members of every age and demographic who are now playing golf in a way they could not before, and who are meeting the game without being intimidated by it. No starter, no tee sheet, no group waiting behind them, no five-hour commitment to find out whether they like it. At their own club, on their own schedule. That is reach a golf course cannot generate on its own. CapacityWithout Added Headcount Fifteen hours a day, six days a week, for 611 days is an operational challenge before it is a membership win. Laredo met it with equipment: two robotic mowers, a robotic picker, and an automated ball pit and wash system. The agronomic benefits are real: Lighter machines cutting more often put less stress on the turf, and a gentler wash cycle extends ball life. The operational benefit is larger. Clean-picking a range normally requires golf operations and course maintenance to negotiate a window in which the facility is unavailable to members. That negotiation is gone. The equipment is not the point— what the club did with the hours it recovered is. The labor a 19-bay facility would otherwise consume in mowing, picking and washing now goes to service, instruction and programming. Technology added the capacity. People still deliver the experience. More to Come In an upcoming McMahon Report, my colleague Christian Clerc will examine two clubs delivering off-course golf in other ways: Midland (Mich.) Country Club and Big Spring Country Club in Kentucky. The McMahon Report® 5 MEMBERS DO NOT RESIGN BECAUSE THE GOLF COURSE GOT WORSE. THEY RESIGN BECAUSE THEY WEREN'T USING IT; USAGE IS A HABIT, AND HABITS FADE OVER A FIVE-MONTH OFFSEASON. Contact us today at 314.744.5040 or www.McMahonGroup.com SMALLER BITES OF GOLF ARE NOT A LESSER VERSION OF THE GAME. THEY ARE THE VERSION MOST OF YOUR MEMBERS HAVE TIME FOR—AND THAT MAKES THEM THE VERSION THAT DETERMINES WHETHER THOSE MEMBERS STAY.

By David Dew, CCM, CCE & Scott Fairbairn, CCM, CCE, Vice Presidents of Club Consulting Six great clubs serving the hottest club marketplace in the nation are pointing the way for how to not only sustain, but continue to build on, success. O ver the past five years, McMahon Group has been fortunate to be able to serve some of the best clubs in the nation as the membership movement continues to shift south, creating waiting lists for many club communities in warmer climates. Clubs in states such as Texas and Tennessee are also benefitting from the southern migration that is occurring, most notably out of the high-tax Northern states and Eastern Canadian provinces. But Florida—with the Atlantic Ocean on one side, the Gulf of America on the other, and plenty of extended winter warmth in between—remains the leader in attracting all ages from other parts of North America to its shores and golf courses, and particularly to its Gulf Coast region. Businesses, too, are now also heading south to escape the tax-crazy Northeast, adding further to the influx of new residents—and potential club members. As a result, we have seen many Florida clubs— particularly in the Naples-to-Sarasota-to-Tampa triangle—become even more of a “winter wonderland” that is attracting people from the eastern half of North America. In the past five years, we have worked with many clubs on Florida’s west coast, including Bonita Bay Club, Club Pelican Bay, Fiddlesticks Country Club, Isla Del Sol Yacht & Country Club, Royal Poinciana Golf Club and Wilderness Country Club, to help them plan major clubhouse, facility and grounds improvements. Yes, there is the occasional hurricane that this region must deal with, but those primarily affect clubs along the coast and, fortunately, very few of the gated club communities. Even with the potential for those disruptions each year, no other area of the country is achieving on the same scale what southwest Florida is doing to attract members and improve club and community facilities. The southward population relocation from expensive Northeast cities has generated a steady stream of potential new club members with millions of dollars in their pockets after selling their homes who will either retire or continue working from home after they relocate—and realize significant tax savings as they do (Florida does not have a personal state income tax). The migration to the region has resulted in existing club communities now being full with long waiting lists to join. Initiation fees have skyrocketed as demand has outpaced supply. There are not enough clubs for all who want to join them, and this situation will, of course, stimulate the emergence of new gated communities with supporting clubs—but they will be more inland and even safer from hurricanes. What’s Their Secret? So what are these clubs and communities offering that is making them so successful? And can we learn anything of value for the entire club industry? Here are some thumbnail sketches of the impact McMahon Group is seeing from this member migration for six clubs we have recently had the honor and pleasure of working with, to conduct member surveys, develop Facility Master Plans and help get improvement projects approved, along with other services: Bonita Bay Club – North Naples, Fla. From its North Naples location, this high-end gated community serves its more than 2,000 homeowner members with multiple golf courses and facilities in two separate locations. Its primary club facility on the coast includes a beach, marina, and full-service offerings, and a newmain clubhouse has just been approved for construction. Frederick Fung, CEO & General Manager Club Pelican Bay – Naples, Fla. This large residential community along the Gulf Coast’s Pelican Bay serves all of the Naples area as a full-service private club. In addition to continuing to improve its 27 holes of championship golf courses, it has built a new clubhouse and other new facilities. Ryan Shaw, CCM, CCE, General Manager/COO Fiddlesticks Country Club – Fort Myers, Fla. This gated community in Fort Myers with full-service club offerings is now starting a major clubhouse renovation project. Located near Fort Myers’ primary airport, Fiddlesticks also continues to enhance its two Arthur Hills golf courses. Al Antonez, CCM, CCE, General Manager What's Going On in Southwest Florida? ...And What Can We Learn? INDUSTRY TRENDS 6 The McMahon Report® October 2026 FIDDLESTICKS COUNTRY CLUB

WILDERNESS COUNTRY CLUB Isla Del Sol Yacht & Country Club – St. Petersburg, Fla. Unique to the Tampa/Clearwater/St. Petersburg area, this beach club and community has its own marina, improved golf facilities and a renovated clubhouse that includes popular dining facilities. Robert Rankin, General Manager Royal Poinciana Golf Club – Naples, Fla. This freestanding, full-service country club has a central Naples location and is one of the finest clubs in the region. A new clubhouse has been approved, with construction to start soon. David Mangan, General Manager Wilderness Country Club – Naples, Fla. As we reported in the April 2026 McMahon Report, a new clubhouse has brought new life to this central Naples club that was founded in 1974 and holds the distinction of being the first gated golf course community in the city. Wilderness’ excellent golf course is now complemented by an elevated dining program, attractive new pro shop and other amenities that have prompted many members to make it their second club in Naples because of its convenient location and high-quality, full-service offering. Alan Raulerson, CCE, CCM, General Manager/COO No End in Sight As they say in real estate, location is everything—and today, Florida is proving this for private clubs and gated communities. Not surprisingly, the success of the clubs featured in this article, along with many others, is also attracting many top club managers and hard-working Board members to come to the region and be part of riding the newwave of success that the combination of a great location, low taxation, winter warmth and ocean/Gulf waters can provide. As a result, in the club world we now see more and more people, members and managers changing the old prescription for success of “Go west, young man” to be “Go south, men and women of all ages, as Florida is the future.” The McMahon Report® 7 Contact us today at 314.744.5040 or www.McMahonGroup.com CLUB PELICAN BAY ROYAL POINCIANA GOLF CLUB BONITA BAY CLUB WILDERNESS COUNTRY CLUB ISLA DEL SOL YACHT & COUNTRY CLUB

By Scott Fairbairn, CCM, CCE, Vice President of Club Consulting A recent Strategic Refresher session that we conducted at a prominent country club produced a revealing discussion about dining. The club offers formal dining, a casual dining room, an adult-only bar, and poolside dining—so on paper, it appears to provide several choices. In practice, however, members coming directly from pickleball, the athletic field or other recreational activities do not feel comfortable entering the clubhouse’s casual dining room in athletic attire. Although it is called “casual,” the room still has tablecloths and retains the atmosphere of a traditional clubhouse restaurant. Because of this, these members head instead to the poolside grill. As a result, the Pool Grill serves not only swimmers and families, but also members arriving from recreational activities throughout the campus. At peak times, the venue gets slammed. The problem is compounded by a menu that has become too complicated for a kitchen intended to provide speed and convenience. Orders accumulate, ticket times grow, staff become overwhelmed and member satisfaction suffers. At first glance, the club appears to have a Pool Grill problem. But our Strategic Refresher with this club revealed that the crowded venue and long ticket times were symptoms of a much broader issue. Different Occasions Require Different Experiences Today’s club members do not want one dining experience. They want choices that correspond with how they are dressed, who they are with, howmuch time they have and what they want from that particular visit. For many clubs, this means providing four distinct dining experiences. These are not four versions of the same restaurant: Each requires a clearly defined audience, atmosphere, menu, service model and operational plan. Recreation dining should be fast, informal, and welcoming to members coming directly from the pool, courts, golf course or athletic field. The menu does not need to be extensive. Burgers, sandwiches, wraps, simple salads, children’s selections and beverages can be fresh and appealing while remaining manageable for the kitchen. The venue’s promise should be quality, consistency and dependable ticket times. Everyday casual dining should offer comfortable indoor and outdoor seating with a broader menu supported by the main kitchen. More importantly, it must feel genuinely casual, as reflected by how its furniture, finishes, entrances and service standards communicate 8 The McMahon Report® One Club, Many Dining Occasions How a Strategic Refresher Can Define the Right Dining Experiences, and Guide the Facility Master Plan PROVIDING DISTINCT DINING EXPERIENCES DOES NOT MEAN OFFERING DIFFERENT VERSIONS OF THE SAME RESTAURANT. EACH REQUIRES A CLEARLY DEFINED AUDIENCE, ATMOSPHERE, MENU, SERVICE MODEL AND OPERATIONAL PLAN. October 2026 CLUB DINING

expectations. If members in recreational attire feel they do not belong, the room is not functioning as casual dining—regardless of what the club calls it. Adult-only social dining fulfills another need. An adult-oriented bar and dining area provides a place for drinks, conversation, shared appetizers and dinner away from the activity of family recreation areas. This does not diminish the club’s commitment to families; it gives adults another reason to remain at the club and provides a natural setting for informal social interaction. Formal and special-occasion dining can continue to support traditions, celebrations and elevated culinary experiences. Formality still has a place when it is intentional, rather than the default experience throughout the clubhouse. The Value of the Strategic Refresher The dining discussion demonstrates why club Boards should establish strategic direction before beginning architectural design. Had the leadership of the club described at the start of this article focused only on utilization numbers and complaints, it might have concluded that its Pool Grill simply needed a larger kitchen, more equipment or additional staff. Our Strategic Refresher session allowed the Board and General Manager to step back and ask why the venue was experiencing so much demand. Through this discussion, it became clear that members were voting with their feet. They were choosing the Pool Grill partly because another dining area did not feel appropriate for the occasion. The conversation reframed the question from “How do we fix the Pool Grill?” to “What combination of dining experiences should the Club provide to meet members’ different needs?” That is the appropriate role of the Board and GM during a Strategic Refresher. The Board helps to define the desired member experience and establish long-term priorities. The GM contributes operating knowledge, including utilization, ticket times, menu complexity, staffing requirements, kitchen capacity and member traffic patterns. The initial direction can then be validated through focus groups, surveys and concept testing. Members can help to clarify what casual dining means to them, how they want to use each venue, and which improvements are important enough to support financially. From Strategic Direction to the Master Plan Once a club defines the experiences it intends to provide, the Facility Master Plan can determine how to deliver them. The planning team can evaluate whether the Pool Grill kitchen needs expansion or simply a more focused menu and efficient configuration. It can explore how the casual dining room might become more welcoming, how indoor and outdoor areas should connect, where adult bar dining belongs and how the main kitchen can support multiple venues. The Master Plan must also address seating capacity, entrances, circulation, service stations and the movement of food, staff, dishes and waste. Probable costs, phasing and funding should be considered before the club advances into detailed design. The distinction is important: The Strategic Refresher defines the dining experiences the club needs. The Facility Master Plan determines the spaces and systems required to deliver them. Members will always vote with their feet—and with their dining dollars. The most successful clubs pay attention not only to where members are going, but also to why they are going there—and what may be pushing them away from somewhere else. A Strategic Refresher uncovers those underlying behaviors before the club invests in the wrong solution, while the Facility Master Plan translates that insight into the right combination of venues, kitchens and experiences. When every dining venue has a clear purpose and every member can find an experience that fits the moment, dining becomes more than a club amenity. It becomes one of the most powerful ways the club brings members together, strengthens their connection and becomes an indispensable part of their lives. The McMahon Report® 9 TODAY’S CLUB MEMBERS DO NOT WANT ONE DINING EXPERIENCE. THEY WANT CHOICES THAT CORRESPOND WITH HOW THEY ARE DRESSED, WHO THEY ARE WITH, HOWMUCH TIME THEY HAVE AND WHAT THEY WANT FROM THAT PARTICULAR VISIT. Contact us today at 314.744.5040 or www.McMahonGroup.com

like ducklings around where the CEOs lived, most within about seven miles. Everything else in the binder was set dressing. It’s worth saying plainly that a fair number of those relocations were mistakes. Companies lost talent they couldn't replace, cut themselves off from the labor market, and crept quietly back toward the city a decade later. Whyte's finding was not that convenience is correct—it's that convenience is powerful. And misunderstanding that power can be strong enough to blind a boardroom to what actually drives a nine-figure decision. The people in Whyte's study are the people on your membership list. Not literally, but in every way that matters: They’re accomplished, analytical, surrounded by process, and—when the decision is personal—governed by the same short, unglamorous instinct to do what’s convenient. Distance is a Price, Not a Verdict Here is where most conversations about location go wrong: We treat drive time as the answer, when it is only the invoice. Every member pays to use your club twice—once in dues, and once in the minutes they spend coming to and from your location. Those minutes have a real cost and can be the most expensive for your best members. So the question is never how far away we are—it is whether what we deliver justifies the total bill. The charts accompanying this article use data from six years of McMahon Group member surveys, representing the answers of more than 74,000 total respondents from By Christian Clerc, AIA Vice President of Club Consulting Every member pays to use your club twice—once in dues, and once in the minutes they spend coming to and from your location. The question is never how far away we are—it is whether what we deliver justifies the total bill. While I was studying urban design at Washington University in St. Louis, we read a study by the urbanist William H. Whyte that I have never been able to forget. It had almost nothing to do with clubs—and everything to do with why some clubs thrive and others fail. In the 1970s and '80s, when blue-chip corporations fled Manhattan for the suburbs, each move was blessed by a Relocation Committee, a consultant, and a bound report thick enough to prop open a fire door. Whyte checked the work. He plotted every new headquarters on a map, then added the one data point the consultants had omitted: the CEO's house. All of the headquarters clustered Driving Value at Any Distance: The Long Drive and the Short Game CLUB MANAGEMENT October 2026 10 The McMahon Report® Every amenity that a country club sells loses relevance as members move farther out, except golf, which gains. This is the argument in one picture: While the distance that must be traveled does not shrink what a member wants, it narrows it to a single thing. A club whose roster sits mostly beyond eight miles is not a country club to its own members—it is a golf club that happens to own a pool. MOST CONVERSATIONS ABOUT LOCATION GO WRONG BECAUSE THEY TREAT DRIVE TIME AS THE ANSWER, WHEN IT IS ONLY THE INVOICE. Source: McMahon Group member surveys, 2020-2026

118 clubs, to analyze how the distance from members’ homes to their clubs affects key factors such as golf play, dining, and perceived value for the cost of belonging. Collectively, they confirm that distance does not decide whether a club succeeds—it decides where a club needs to be excellent to clear its own price. The Clock is Ticking Inside fifteen minutes, the price of time is low, so you have to be excellent at providing a frictionless experience. Your business is frequency. Members stop in because it costs them nothing: nine holes before dinner, a workout that does not blow the morning, a Tuesday drink that was not planned. You are competing with their kitchen and their couch. An everyday club that behaves like a formal occasion is throwing away its only structural advantage, and charging for grandeur its members are not, in fact, buying. Outside fifteen minutes, the price of time is high, so you have to be excellent at something singular. Nobody “drops by”—every visit is a decision, and that decision needs a justification your members can say out loud: the golf course, the view, the room, the reputation, the things they cannot get closer to home. The threshold is brutal and non-negotiable: Is it worth the drive? A drive that’s merely pleasant can lead to a resignation letter. Notice what this means: Neither bucket is the safe one. A great destination beats a mediocre neighbor every time. In St. Louis, a golfer will pass three clubs to play championship golf at Bellerive. But a member at a neighborhood club would skip Bellerive entirely because he values dinner on a Wednesday with the people who live next door. Two sets of values, two different purchases. Where Multi-Location Clubs Win—and Lose This is where the stakes get real, because the portfolio of multi-location clubs can hold both kinds of distance-related strategies at once. Most mistakes come from running one playbook across all of them. Your in-town site is an everyday club and should be judged on visits per member. Your out-of-town site is a destination and should be judged on whether it is genuinely worth the drive. Same club, opposite strategies, different definitions of a good year. Judge the destination on frequency and it will look like a failure. Judge the everyday club on grandeur and you will renovate away Contact us today at 314.744.5040 or www.McMahonGroup.com The McMahon Report® 11 Nearly a quarter of country club members living within four miles of the club never play a round of golf. That figure falls by nearly a third among members eight or more miles out, while heavy play rises. The convenient member includes a large block of people paying golf dues for a dining and pool membership. The distant member has already been screened. Golf clubs show the same pattern from a higher floor: Only 4 percent of far-away members play zero rounds, against 8 percent of those who live closer. This is the strongest finding from the study: Members who live eight or more miles out from the club eat dinner out just as often as members down the road, with roughly half of each group going out eight or more times a month. What changes is where the two groups choose to eat. The member that’s farther away takes twice as many of those dinners somewhere else entirely, and is twice as likely to take none at the club at all. This shows that while clubs do not face weaker demand based on distance, they are losing a competition they’re already in to restaurants that happen to be closer. Source: McMahon Group member surveys, 2020-2026 Source: McMahon Group member surveys, 2020-2026

the very casualness that makes people come on a Tuesday. Then you raise dues to pay for a renovation, which turns a strength into a bad trade. What causes failure is more subtle. Two everyday clubs that are twenty minutes apart do not expand a market— they split one, and often neither reaches the critical mass needed to stay alive. That is not growth; it is division with better signage. So the question for every site in a portfolio is not whether it’s a good club. It’s whether it earns its place by reaching a market the others cannot, or by delivering something worth its price to a member who has other options. Making Distance Pay Off This is where capital investment earns its keep. Amenities are how a club drives its own future, through the fitness center that lets a workout fit inside a Tuesday morning, or the golf course that makes 45 minutes in the car look like a bargain. Those are different projects, justified on different grounds and judged by different numbers. Wasted capital in the club business is rarely spent on the wrong quality—it’s spent on the right quality aimed at the wrong distance members will travel for it. So weigh the two things that members actually feel: the minutes it costs them to come to your club, and the value they get in return. Get those two right, and the case for a capital project starts writing itself. If you are an existing club, you can't control the distance; it's baked in. But there is a process to understand what matters to your members, and what facilities will deliver the experiences they value. Give us a call if you need someone to help navigate it with your members. October 2026 12 The McMahon Report® While every club Board assumes that the distant member is the one who wavers on price, the data on satisfaction and value for both golf and country clubs says the opposite. Two things are probably happening at once to lead to these results. First, the farthest-away members who were not getting their money’s worth have already resigned, so the answers for that group reflect survivors. Second, proximity buys tolerance: The convenient membership group (under four miles) collects people who joined because it was easy, rather than because they loved it. Either reading points in the same direction: The members who are softer on value are the ones who live nearby. Among golf club members under 46, distance adds both masculinity and youth to the roster at the same time. The close-in, young-member group is nearly evenly split by gender; eight miles out, however, women are only one in eight. The same group is also the youngest and newest to join the club, and 52 percent still have children at home. That combination—young and male, and driving with kids in the house—is either the best growth segment or the narrowest one, depending on whether the club has anything to sell for the rest of the family. WASTED CAPITAL IN THE CLUB BUSINESS IS RARELY SPENT ON THE WRONG QUALITY—IT’S SPENT ON THE RIGHT QUALITY THAT’S AIMED AT THE WRONG DISTANCE MEMBERS WILL TRAVEL FOR IT. Source: McMahon Group member surveys, 2020-2026 Source: McMahon Group member surveys, 2020-2026

ANSWER: When no one there knows your name (not the Board, Manager or other members). C lub membership is personal. It is not just about playing golf, tennis, swimming or dining. It is about people, friendships and enjoying life with people we like and have something in common with. Who likes to play golf or tennis alone or dine by themself? No one! The biggest threats to a private club’s existence are when it becomes impersonal, is too business-focused on eliminating operating losses, has a Board that’s arrogant in how it governs, doesn’t listen to members’ wants, and no longer pursues a social purpose of bringing members and their families together. At McMahon Group, we serve over 2,000 clubs of all sizes and types. We see what makes great clubs—and why clubs fall from greatness. The key factor for a club’s success, no matter what type of club it is, is providing social connectiveness among members. For dining clubs, the biggest challenge is not necessarily having the best food, but to provide the best place to enjoy good food and have members connect socially. A dining club that doesn’t provide members with good social interaction just becomes a restaurant that charges dues, and will never be successful. By Bill McMahon, Sr., AIA, OAA Founder Likewise, a golf club that just has a good golf course without also promoting strong social interaction among its golfing members is really just another place with 18 holes. If that’s all a member wants, there are plenty of golf courses without dues. But a good golf club knows how to make itself member-friendly—because the best part of being a member is the fun we have being together before, during and after playing golf, as we build friendships for life. The Board and Manager’s Responsibility So what can we do as managers and Board members to build and foster a member-friendly club that attracts and retains members by promoting strong social bonding among them? It all starts at the top with the Board and management team, who need to work together to create a friendly club atmosphere and culture that is so contagious, members can’t wait to be at their club. The Board has to communicate a member-first attitude that defines and promotes the club as the place where members and their families want to be. The club must have friendly policies, good facilities, high-quality services and good communication that keeps members informed and encourages them to participate on committees and serve on the Board. A Truly “Special” Touch From managers and department heads to every staff person, the emphasis must always be on being friendly and helpful to members and their families. A good example of a staff-driven success story is what my grandson, Drew, recently accomplished at the Little Harbor Club in Harbor Springs, Mich. Drewworks in the club’s most casual restaurant that serves hundreds of members daily. When a certain lady member often had complaints about the food in this very popular dining room, Drew took it upon himself to please her. He crafted a special sandwich that she loved so much, she promoted it and called it the “Drew Special.” She now raves about the club’s food, eats there all the time and tells all of her friends to try the “Drew Special.” This was just another great example of how a little bit of love and care can help to build a great club that good managers like Little Harbor’s General Manager/COO, Jed Avery, CCM, promote through their leadership (see more about Little Harbor’s successful approach to staffing and building a service-first culture in the August 2026 McMahon Report). To make sure your club remains a true club, the secret to success is to not just be a place with a golf course, tennis courts or a restaurant. Add a big dose of fun and social connectiveness generated by the Board, management and membership, and you will end up with one of the best clubs for everyone to enjoy. Remember: “Building friendships for life among your membership also keeps them members for life in your club.” THE KEY FACTOR FOR A CLUB’S SUCCESS, NO MATTER WHAT TYPE OF CLUB IT IS, IS PROVIDING THE SOCIAL CONNECTIVENESS AMONG MEMBERS. THE BOARD AND MANAGEMENT TEAM MUST COMMUNICATE A MEMBER-FIRST ATTITUDE THAT DEFINES AND PROMOTES THE CLUB AS THE PLACE WHERE MEMBERS AND THEIR FAMILIES WANT TO BE. The McMahon Report® 13 Membership Question For Today: When is a Club No Longer a Club? CLUB MANAGEMENT Contact us today at 314.744.5040 or www.McMahonGroup.com

ties for members to have meaningful social interactions around the programs and activities that the facilities provide. Sports Simulators DO: Make an early determination of the simulators’ purpose and goals in your club environment. There are two primary drivers for simulators at clubs: 1) Golf Lessons and Performance and 2) Competition, Social Gathering and Extending the Club Season. These purposes can and do overlap, but the primary purpose will guide the effort to find the best place for the simulators in your building or on your campus. Find a place to test the concept. We have worked with clubs that have put up temporary simulators in bag rooms, ballrooms, boardrooms, and pool snack bars. The early engagement with members can provide a test case for the best eventual final solution. Treat simulator space in the clubhouse as a social lounge first, and a technology room second. Having some aspect of social gathering is important, even for training simulators. The space should be designed so it can be used at times for informal gathering and competition. The best-performing simulator rooms have comfortable seating, a bar or beverage service nearby, and sightlines that let non-playing members watch and mingle. A simulator bay tucked into a leftover storage roomwith no gathering space around it will get used, but it won’t build community. DON’T: Assume one bay is enough. A single simulator creates a scheduling bottleneck almost immediately, once word gets around the club. Two to four bays seems to be the sweet spot for most clubs, to allowmember-guest play, lessons, and league nights to take place without members feeling like they have to fight for tee times indoors. By Glen Selligman, AIA Director of Architecture 14 The McMahon Report® A s part of its “Outlook” Pulse Survey for 2026 that was conducted at the beginning of this year, McMahon Group asked club managers and Board members to identify the capital-improvement areas (beyond the golf course) that they feel are important for their club but had not yet been addressed. As shown in the table at right, survey respondents cited a number of different areas in their responses. In earlier issues of the McMahon report this year, we provided some “dos and don’ts,” based on our experience at McMahon helping clubs with their facility planning, that should be kept in mind to give capital-improvement projects the best chance for success in the areas that were at the top of the list (dining-room updates, adding/expanding pickleball indoors and out, fitness/wellness and casual bars/lounges). (For copies of those articles, call or e-mail Alison McMahon at 314-744-5040 or amcmahon@ mcmahongroup.com) Here are some thoughts for the two areas that are next on the list: sports simulators and resort-style pools. As always, keep in mind that a key metric for successful facilities of any type should always be to create them in a way that offers opportuni- "Dos and Don'ts" for Successful Club Improvements Part III CLUB ARCHITECTURE Capital Improvements % Dining-room updates 49% Adding/expanding pickleball (including indoors) 31% Fitness/wellness 30% Casual bar/lounge 29% Sports simulators 28% Resort-style pool 23% Children’s activity room 20% Adding/expanding platform tennis 7% Adding bocce 6% Wi-Fi café 6% Beyond the golf course, what are some capital-improvement areas that you feel are important for your club that have not been addressed? (Mark all that apply.) August 2026 A KEY METRIC FOR SUCCESSFUL FACILITIES OF ANY TYPE SHOULD ALWAYS BE TO CREATE THEM IN A WAY THAT OFFERS OPPORTUNITIES FOR MEMBERS TO HAVE MEANINGFUL SOCIAL INTERACTIONS AROUND THE PROGRAMS AND ACTIVITIES THAT THE FACILITIES PROVIDE.

to our Pulse Survey added many other areas to the list that they would also like to see improved, including: ballroom space, the golf shop, kitchens, the lobby, maintenance facilities, office space, overnight accommodations, parking lots, and tennis facilities and courts, both indoors and outdoors. In future issues of the McMahon Report, our Architecture column will continue to take in-depth looks at the “dos and don’ts” for these and other areas of the club that showed up on the Pulse Survey’s capital-improvement “wish list.” And don’t forget: McMahon Group experts are always available to come take a look at any area or facility at your club that you’re targeting for improvement, as part of our complimentary First Impressions Visit that includes a report with recommendations for how to best approach making an effective change. For more information and to schedule your First Impressions Visit, call or e-mail Alison McMahon at 314-744-5040 or amcmahon@mcmahongroup.com. During the opening session of the Club Management Association of America’s 2026 Capital Improvements Symposium, held August 10-11 at The Chicago Club, McMahon Group Founder Bill McMahon, Sr. answered questions from Joe Krenn, CCM, CCE, ECM, CEO & General Manager, Farmington Country Club, on the keys to planning and executing successful facility projects. His responses emphasized the importance of setting the vision and roadmap for both the current club and its future through Strategic and Master Plans; developing a true three-way partnership between the Board, management and membership that revolves around identifying and following member preferences and helping members understand the reasoning and need for capital expenditures; and focusing on members’ “ROE" (return on experience) rather than ROI. On the Symposium’s second day, McMahon Group Chairman Frank Vain joined Bill McMahon, Sr. and Dave Linden and Michael Cottick of Bulley & Andrews, a Chicago-based construction firm specializing in club projects, for a session on “Construction Scheduling & Project Controls.” McMahon Group’s presentation focused on the General Manager’s role in planning and managing projects, and the importance of developing and following Master Plans to set a holistic vision that properly guides long-range project development and focuses consistently on the member experience, rather than “what needs to be fixed.” For slides from the presentation, contact Alison McMahon at amcmahon@mcmahongroup.com. McMahon Group was once again a presenting partner for the Symposium, which is attended by club General Managers, Facilities Managers and Board members, and focuses on construction management in clubs and the competencies a club managementprofessional needs to complete a successful project, renovation, or deconstruction. erage service is one of the highest-return investments a club can make in pool-deck engagement and satisfaction. DON’T: Treat the pool as an isolated department separate from the rest of the campus. The most successful pool renovations we’ve been involved with are planned in coordination with adjacent fitness, tennis/ pickleball, and dining facilities, so members can move easily between activities throughout the day, rather than experiencing the pool as a disconnected amenity. Overlook operational realities like deck capacity, restroom/changing facilities, and support spaces when expanding a pool’s footprint. A modern resort-style club pool might have four or five times as much deck space as water area. A beautiful new pool that can’t comfortably support the crowd it draws—or that creates bottlenecks in service—will generate as many complaints as compliments. In addition to the remaining items on the list on pg. 14, respondents Underestimate technology’s short shelf life. Simulator hardware and software evolve quickly, and the room’s architecture, wiring, and infrastructure should be designed so components can be upgraded or swapped out over time without a full renovation Resort-Style Pools DO: Think beyond the swim program. Today’s most successful club pools function as a family and social hub— with zero-entry access, shallow lounging shelves, splash features for young children, and adjacent shaded seating and sunning areas that encourage members to stay for hours, and not just for laps or swim team practice. Locate properly sized food-and-beverage service areas close enough to the pool deck, so members don’t have to leave the pool area (or get fully dressed) to get a drink or a bite. A great pool bar has often become one of the most visited and popular social-gathering areas at many of our clubs, even for non-swimmers. Efficient and expand food-and-bevCapital Improvements Symposium Recap The McMahon Report® 15 Contact us today at 314.744.5040 or www.McMahonGroup.com

SCHEDULE YOUR FIRST IMPRESSIONS VISIT TODAY! McMahon Group offers our complimentary “First Impressions Visit” as an initial step toward club excellence, helping your club and management identify issues, analyze the current situation, and receive detailed guidance from experienced specialists. The visit includes facility tours, leadership meetings, and a customized report that provides an initial roadmap to support your club’s growth and success. With over 40 years of experience serving more than 2,000 clubs, we are committed to supporting your club’s journey toward continued excellence. There is no charge for this visit besides reimbursement for travel expenses. T H E S O U R C E F O R P R I V A T E C L U B E X C E L L E N C E™ Rest in Peace THE CLUB WORLD MOURNS THE LOSS OF ONE OF OUR OWN. MATT SERVED AS THE GENERAL MANAGER OF THE COUNTRY CLUB OF MIRASOL IN PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA FOR 23 YEARS. MATT WAS THE WINNER OF THE 2023 EXCELLENCE IN CLUB MANAGEMENT® AWARDS' JAMES H. BREWER AWARD. HE WILL BE MISSED BY ALL, REST IN PEACE MATT. Matt Lambert CCM, CAM, ECM We Can Help Make Your Club Successful Click to download our brochures today! OVER 2000 CLUBS SERVED $3.5 BILLION RAI SED Scan to view all of our online brochures 40+ I N BUSI NESS YEARS

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTY4MTkx